First Capital Connect: Your Ideas
We want to make your experience with First Capital Connect better. And we know you’ve got some great ideas. Let us know what we can improve and how we should do it. Check out other people’s ideas and vote for your favourites. We aim to respond to most comments within five working days.
-
Simple. Make the trains run on time.
Simple. Make the trains run on time.
440 votesstarted ·
AdminFirst Capital Connect
(Admin, firstcapitalconnect.co.uk)
responded
Hi.
Our goal is for as many of our trains as possible to run on time, with as few delays or problems as possible. Of course, things do not always go as planned, and we know this causes frustration. Sometimes problems occur when we make a mistake, and sometimes as the result of other factors – often things controlled by the other companies and agencies that run the lines we use. It can be quite complicated. So, yes, we will keep trying to make the trains run on time, as you quite fairly suggest.
If you do have any other ideas please feel free to suggest then on this site.
-
Make compensation a genuinely worthwhile amount and deduct it from what you pay Network Rail for the service they provide you.
Network Rail seem to be at fault for the vast majority of delays and cancellations due to infrastructure issues. Therefore, as you have no other service provider options, hit them directly and hopefully that should get them to take their own service provision to you, and thus us, considerably more seriously.
208 votesThanks for your suggestion.
The details of how payments are made to Network Rail for use of their infrastructure are determined within our franchise. This is an agreement made with the Department for Transport and cannot be modified.
Network Rail is fined for poor performance and we compensate customers under the Delay Repay scheme. Industry ombudsmen such as London TravelWatch and Passenger Focus are looking to make Delay Repay standard for all rail franchises. Compared to other compensation schemes it is considered generous, paying out for all delays regardless of their cause, including fatalities and weather related issues – not covered by some other schemes.
-
When there is disruption. make sure all your staff know what has happened and what is being done to fix it. Everyone has a phone, text them!
The biggest failure with FCC is information. Last night no one had a clue what had happened, or what was being done about it. Staff at Farringdon were sending passengers to St Pancras. Staff at St Pancras were sending passengers to Kentish Town or East Midlands Trains. East Midlands Trains staff were not letting FCC passengers onto the EMT services. Then an FCC train arrived at St Pancras upper level but with no announcement. At no point in the evening did I receive a single text, tweet or email to help me get home.
180 votesstarted ·
AdminFirst Capital Connect
(Admin, firstcapitalconnect.co.uk)
responded
Hi there, we know how important it is to give out clear concise information.
We have developed an app for staff to receive information that is station specific to them. The messages are updated within service delivery centres and pushed out through the app this has been rolled out and we are in the process of embedding this.
When we go in to major service disruption, which is normally when services are delayed over 20 minutes ore more, an industry standard called Customer Service Level 2 kicks in. When this happens (and all other operators know we have go into CSL2 disruption because they receive an automated message to say that we have) ticket acceptance on other Train Operating Companies comes into play.
East Midlands trains should accept passengers for Luton and Bedford stations during severe service disruption (we will look at why they didn’t)
We are also looking at… more
-
Make a compensation app avaiable so that, once registered, we only have to press one or two buttons to make a claim.
The app will know where customers are because of GPS so will give them the (hopefully correct) option on screen of what late-running train they have just left. At a touch of a button, the passenger will be able to confirm. If the correct option does not appear the user will have the opportunity to manually input the details.The lateness of the train will, of course, be recorded centrally so the user won't have to enter those sorts of details. The app could record all claims made by each individual and the result and would make information on claims on… more
107 votesstarted ·
AdminFirst Capital Connect
(Admin, firstcapitalconnect.co.uk)
responded
Hi Again,
This is something that we are committed to doing. There are a few contractual issues that we are working through at the moment, but will keep you posted on how this project is progressing.
-
Make season tickets (incl annual ticket) less expensive. How can you carry on increasing fares when most people are not getting a pay rise?!
There is no justification for the yearly increase in fares we have to accept, when most people have had no pay increases for quite some time or even had to take a pay cut. Passengers have no choice and are forced to use FCC. You are slowly forcing lower paid people to give up trying to work in London because the exorbitant train fares simply do not make it economically viable anymore. When will you remember you are meant to be providing public transport, not transport for a wealthy elite?!
85 votesHi there, and thank you for your suggestion
We appreciate that this is a difficult time for many of our customers and no one wants to see an increase in fares.
Fares have always been set against the Retail Price index (RPI), the rise was RPI +1% This forms part of the government’s wider strategy of moving the cost of running the country’s railways away from the tax payer and towards those buying tickets. In the longer-term, the industry is working together to keep on cutting costs as a way of helping to limit future fare rises and offering better value for money for taxpayers.
We do aim to set unregulated fares at a level which encourage people to use our trains and we have kept most of the fares the same or set them even lower this year.
It is worth pointing out that all of the… more
-
If held then regular announcements from drivers, every 5 mins, even if they don't know how long delay will be..... It's about reassurance.
Regular updates and PA's from Drivers gives that personal touch and reassurance.
65 votesHi there and thanks for your suggestion. We expect all of our drivers to make regular announcements when we are in service disruption. I will say that when the train is moving the drivers will only make an announcement when they feel it is safe to do so.
It’s a bit of a hard one for us to police to be honest, as we have to be on a train at the right time during disruption to listen to what a driver is or isn’t saying. T
the other thing i will say is it’s very hard sometimes for the drivers to get the information from Network Rail signal box, as the box are so busy fielding calls to trains that are caught up in disruption, sometimes that can be unto 20 or 30 trains they have to call one by one. So sometimes it does take a while for… more
-
Stop squishing us like sardines
Every morning seems to get worse, there isn't physically any more room on the train for us to move along. (Brighton - Bedford morning service)
56 votesstarted ·
AdminFirst Capital Connect
(Admin, firstcapitalconnect.co.uk)
responded
We do understand how crowded it is on the TL route, hence the government investment for new longer trains, station upgrades, longer platform with the introduction the Thameslink Programme. New trains longer trains arrive in 2015
The objective of the Your Ideas site is for customers to suggest specific ideas they have that we can review and then implement if possible.
We have a Customer Relations department to deal with complaints which your idea seems to be.
If you do have any suggestions about tangible ideas that we can review please feel free to suggest them here.
-
Old and cold trains
06.00 Hassocks to London- Why are the heating systems either not switched on or not working on these very cold mornings
52 votesHi there,
Thanks for your suggestion
First Capital Connect prepares its fleet for winter by carrying out a series of additional maintenance checks in the depot during autumn. Each of our 6 train types requires a slightly different engineering approach to ensure that the heating is fully operational during the colder months.
During the recent cold spell, it has come to light that because of a new issue, on some of our trains the heating is not working effectively. This is more common on the class 319 trains operating between Bedford and Brighton and to a much lesser extent on the class 365 and 321 operating on the Great Northern route.
The additional checks in the autumn specifically test thermostats, heating elements and the rest of the control and protection system. Any components that were found to be defective were repaired, replaced or reset. The work involved was significant and… more
-
Barcode tickets
To remove reliance on paper tickets, there could be a trial using barcode ticketing for mobile devices.
This trial would use the ‘Rail Tickets’ mobile retail application (available on iPhone, Android, BlackBerry and Nokia). You use the app to purchase your ticket, which would then then stored as a barcode on your phone - readable by sensors at the station ticket barriers.
At first, this would only be available for certain types of daily tickets between Cambridge and London Kings Cross. If successful, the idea could be opened up to other journeys.
Do you think there’s any value in this… more
48 votesstarted ·
AdminFirst Capital Connect
(Admin, firstcapitalconnect.co.uk)
responded
Update on this project; 30th March 2012
We will be conducting a trial shortly on direct services between London King’s Cross and Cambridge on Barcode tickets.
Customer will be able to purchase tickets from their phone using our application, the phone then becomes the ticket in essence. Special ticket readers are being installed at London King’s Cross and Cambridge to read them.
As soon as the trail is complete we will update you further.
-
When trouble in central London stops trains, just have them stop/start at Blackfriars & Kentish Town. That way people can still get home.
When there are the frequent problems around Farringdon or other parts of the central London section, the whole line comes to a standstill. It then appears to take several hours before a contingency plan of running Kentish Town to Bedford and Blackfriars to Brighton is instigated. Surely this plan can kick in within minutes of the problem being identified, keeping passengers moving and reducing the disruption.
45 votesHi Andy, thanks for your suggestion
We do have contingency plans, these are written in conjunction with Network Rail as of course they own and manage the infrastructure that our trains run on. The problem is when things happen it all depends on the nature of the problem, and to the signalling problems last Monday we couldn’t turn trains around at certain locations because of where the signalling fault happened,
Blackfriars at the moment does not have the signalling equipment in place for us to turn trains there, but it will do next year when the signalling and new track and bays are in place. That’s why we have to turn around at City Thameslink, but this was compounded on the Monday night because we couldn’t use the full length of the platform due to the nature of the signal failure.
It’s a bit like trying to put back together… more
-
Pay compensation to take into account journey times
Pay compensation rates which acknowledge the actual journy time to make it more fair. For example, if I am delayed 20 minutes on a journey that should only take 20 minutes then that is a 100% delay. However, a delay of 20 minutes on a journey which takes an hour is only a 33% delay. Whilst they are both unacceptable, having a flat rate of 30 mins delay for everyone is ridiculous.
38 votesThanks for your suggestion.
We compensate customers under the delay repay scheme, which industry Ombudsman such as London TravelWatch and Passenger Focus are looking to make standard in all Rail franchise as the compensation we offer is actually generous as we pay out for all delays, such as fatalities and weather related issues, under other compensation schemes you would not be reimbursed for this. The delay repay scheme has been set to activated after 30 minutes of disruptions. The scheme we offer forms part of our Passenger Charter which is set within our franchise agreement with the Department for Transport and can not be modified.
Based on this your idea has been declined, however if you do have any other Ideas that you think we can implement then let us know.
-
Provide a daily list (and archive) on the FCC website why trains are delayed or cancelled
Provide a daily list (and archive) on the FCC website why trains are delayed or cancelled
37 votesunder review ·
AdminFirst Capital Connect
(Admin, firstcapitalconnect.co.uk)
responded
Hi there
We will have a look in to this for you.
-
Turn down the heating at peak hours
Why are the heaters on full especially when the trains are full of passengers at rush hour? Most people get on the train with their outdoor coats, and there is insufficient space to remove them. When the train becomes so packed that further passengers cannot get on, having the heaters on makes it extremely uncomfortable, and possibly dangerous, for everyone in the carriage.
35 votesHi Simon
The heating actually works via thermostats, the driver has no way of turning the heat up or down, to an ambient temperature of 21 degrees.
The problem that we have is that the trains we have inherited and quite old, and the heating systems sometimes fail, if it’s boiling hot on the train it means a faulty thermostat, just report this and the train time and coach number this can be found above the internal doors. Each coach has it’s own thermostat which is why we need this information.
You can report any hot/cold trains to our customer relations team or via Twitter @Firstcc
If you have any ideas, please feel free to leave them on this site.
-
Improve the statistics you produce
1. Report the number of Thameslink route cancellations alone - currently you only publish combined FCC cancellation although you do provide the Thameslink only % of delays. What are you hiding?
2. Currently you class a train as 'late' if more than 5 mins late at its final destination. This is of little meaning on the thameslink route. You should change to 5 mins late at St Pancras International/Farringdon where a vast majority of people get off.
3. Finally 5 minutes is too generous to be classed as on time. 2 minutes is more realistic although it is still late!
34 votesHi there,
Thanks for your suggestion; I can assure you we’re not hiding anything
It’s a balance between detail and readability with having a single route-wide poster. We publish some statistics at a route level and cancellations at a company level to make the poster more readable. Adding more information is likely to make it harder to understand for some customers.
We do record and monitor performance for both the Thameslink and Great Northern routes. We are always happy to provide this information for ad-hoc request. The last two period percentages are 3.31% and 4.26% respectively.
We are currently looking at a project to publish more detailed performance information on our website.
The 5 minute threshold is an industry standard defined by the Department for Transport and reported on across the industry.
The Thameslink route is an industry exception in that Public Performance Measure for punctuality is measured twice for… more
-
Stickers showing where to store bikes on Electrostar trains
On FCC's older trains (the 319s?) between Brighton and London, I've seen useful stickers by certain doors, showing the locations of the spaces to stow bikes.
But on the the newer Electrostar trains (377s) I've seen, it's not clear where passengers with bikes should board. Are bikes supposed to be stored in the area near the accessible toilet, as on Southern 377s?
If this is the best location for bikes to be stored, some stickers on the doors (as used on older trains) would make it clearer to cycling passengers, and maybe leave more space in more crowded areas of… more
28 votes -
More information screens at St Albans
It would be useful if there was an information screen at the front end (towards London) on platform 3 at St Albans as there is no information at all if waiting towards the front of the train. It would also be helpful if announcements (especially platform alterations) were louder and not made when a train is passing through the station. Finally, a second set of stair cases towards the London end of the platforms would prevent overcrowding on the current stairs.
27 votesunder review ·
AdminFirst Capital Connect
(Admin, firstcapitalconnect.co.uk)
responded
Hi there
Thanks you for your suggestion.
I have passed this on to our Customer Information Team, and I will get back to you.
If you have any further ideas, please feel free to leave them on this site.
-
Seriously? After all these years running the Thameslink route you need *us* to tell *you* how to do it properly?
If you really haven't got a clue what it is us ''customers'' want from our TOC then there really isn't any hope is there? How desperate are you to look as though you are concerned for our welfare? And... ooh look... concern for our welfare just as you are entering into a new franchise process... Any co-incidence there?
But seriously, if you *really* need to be told what we want... try these for starters:
Affordable travel.
Clean trains.
Correctly heated trains.
Trains running on time.
Trains the correct length of carriages.
Courteous staff... gateline, platform and drivers.
Informative staff... gateline,… more23 votesHi there,
Thanks for your suggestion.
We aim to run all of our train services on time. I can see where you’re coming from on many of your points raised. Train heating has become a real issue, many of the trains we have inherited in our franchise are very old, the heating fails and it’s hard to get replacement parts. Our Engineering team are working to get this fixed.
Just let us know when staff are not being courteous to you, there is no excuse for rudeness and we will address that.
We are really committed to giving you all the information you need when things go wrong. But we do have a period of between 30-60 minutes when we go into major service disruption where our Service Delivery Centres are dealing with the mammoth task of rebuilding the train service, inputting all the details in the Customer Information Systems… more
-
Tickets that dont de-magnetise. Educate your staff that issuing a replacement is a customer service and not to be treated as scam prevention
Sell tickets that dont de-magnetise so easily and then fail at the gates. If you cant do this then at least educate your staff that issuing a replacement ticket is a customer service and not to treat the customer as if they are running some kind of ticket scam!
23 votesHi Neil,
Thanks for your suggestion.
I can see where you’re coming from on the season tickets. Paper tickets are a Rail Industry standard, and they need to be changed nationally. I know that this is something that is being looked into.
If you do have any problems with staff then please let us know via our Customer Relations team who can be contacted on 08450264700 or via Twitter @Firstcc.
If you have any further ideas or suggestions, please feel free to leave them on this site.
-
Station adopters
A 'Station Adopter' scheme would aim to help improve links between First Capital Connect, local communities and customers living near unstaffed railway stations.
Unstaffed stations should be kept as clean and pleasant environments. This scheme would encourage regular feedback about the facilities at the station to help make sure they meet the high standards that customers want.
There would be a need for volunteers who are interested in the good standards of their local train station, who would be called 'station adopters', to report on litter, graffiti, vandalism, lighting, information help points and timetable information.
As an adopter, there would… more
22 votes -
The London-Cambridge express train bound for Cambridge should stop at Hitchin in the morning
The express train already has to slow down to negotiate the junction at Hitchin, so it wouldn’t have a huge effect on the time taken if the train stopped there. The express train also appears to get caught behind the slow train before it reaches Cambridge giving an opportunity for the train to catch up any time lost at Hitchin. The current timetabling appears to reflect this as the express trains are scheduled to take a couple of extra minutes in the morning.
This would have the obvious benefit of seriously reducing the travelling time to Cambridge from Hitchin. And… more
22 votesI’ve passed this on to our train planning department for them to have a look at.